Obed Burnham Walker                               1838 – 1839

William N. Slason                                         1839 – 1844

J. Johnson                                                     1844 – 1845

Thomas C. Merrill                                        1846 – 1847

Asa Howard Gould                                      1847 – 1856            Not Known                                                    1857 - 1873

 R. (Richard ?) D. Porter                                1873-1879

Robert Glendinning Farley                         1878-1880  

Vacant                                                           1880-1881

Charles F. Clark                                            1881-1884

Not Known                                                   1884-1890

Chas. W Stables                                                1890

E. W. Harrington                                                1891

F. S. Todd                                                      1892 – 1896

Thomas McDonald                                      1896 – 1899

S. R. Belyea                                                   1899 – 1902

A. H. Seavers                                                1903 – 1905

C. N. Barton                                                  1906 – 1909

A. E. Bradford                                               1909 – 1913

C. Sterling                                                      1914- 1916

Mann                                                             1916 – 1919

F. W. Grant                                                   1920 – 1925

Collins                                                            1925 – 1928

Vacant – Pulpit Supply                                1928 – 1929

E. D. Cram                                                     1929 – 1930

Walter Lyons                                                1930 – 1974

Frank Tibbits                                                 1975 – 1978

Victor Stanley                                               1978 – 1980

Lee Cross                                                       1980 - ----  

Harry E. Hall                                                     ---- - ----

Lewis Holiday                                                   ---- - 1992

Alfred Page                                                   1993 – 1999

Joseph Rosebush                                         2000 – 2001

Robert Meister (Interim)                                  2001

Robert S. Oliver Sr.                                      2002 – 2004

Johnathan Ledford                                      2005 – 2008

Dr. Paul Emery (Interim)                                  2008

Christopher Myers                                      2009 – 2012

Gregory Hensley                                          2012 – 2013

Robert S. Oliver Jr.                                       2014 – Current

​